No, this is not some random NFL question. There is a reason for it. Yesterday former Giants running back Tiki Barber damn near set the sports world on fire when he said he believes Eli Manning is now better than his older brother Peyton. I personally am a Giants diehard fan and as of this moment I still can not say Eli is better, even though I wish it was true. That can definitely change over the next couple seasons though. Barber did make some good points regarding how much better Eli seems to be in crunch time when you really need someone to step up, which Eli seems to be the king of. But if we really compare the two famous brothers it is hard to compare Eli’s career stats to Peyton who seems to be on his way to re-writing NFL record books. Not too mention the high level of play Peyton showed last season coming off neck surgery and getting up there in age. It is still a good argument because fans should be able to see that Eli has the potential to finish with the better career. So with that said, let us know what you think! Hit the jump and take the poll.

@IamJOE357

ESPN